Listing courtesy of Irish Realty · Listing agent: Stephen Smith · steve.smith@irishrealty.net
732 W Michigan Street
New Carlisle, IN 46552
- 3-car garage
- Basement
- Bedrooms
- 5
- Bathrooms
- 3
- Living area
- 3,702 sq ft
- Lot
- 0.92 ac
- Year built
- 1860
- Type
- Site-Built Home
- Listed
- July 24, 2026
- MLS #
- 202629986
About this home
Step into a piece of local history at the former Theodore Borden House rich in character, where timeless Italianate architecture meets thoughtful modern updates. From the moment you enter, you'll be captivated by soaring 12-foot ceilings, and beautiful hardwood floors. This impressive property features 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, including a private 2-bedroom, 1-bath living suite at the rear of the home, offering exceptional flexibility for multi-generational living, guests, a home office, or additional workspace. At the heart of the home is a fully remodeled kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances, with Quartz countertops thoughtfully designed to blend modern functionality with the home's historic charm. Extensive updates provide peace of mind for years to come, including a newer roof on both the home and pole barn, new HVAC system, new plumbing, new water heater, updated bathrooms, new gutters, new landscaping, new sidewalks, a new water service line, and a newly paved commercial parking lot. Outside, you'll find an attached single-car garage, a spacious pole barn offering abundant storage or workshop space, and beautifully improved grounds that enhance both the property's curb appeal and functionality.
Monthly payment estimate
$4,067/mo
- Principal & interest
- $3,147
- Property taxes
- $752
- Homeowners insurance
- $168
- Rate: Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average for the week of October 1, 2026.
- Taxes: the seller's 2025 bill as reported to the MLS. Yours may differ once your own deductions apply.
- Insurance: estimated at 0.35% of the price per year.
- An estimate, not a loan offer. Your rate and payment depend on your credit, loan program and down payment.
Get pre-approved
Know your real budget before you tour, and make a stronger offer. We'll connect you with a local lender.
Property details
Interior
- Levels
- Two
- Total rooms
- 8
- Total area
- 7,404 sq ft
- Finished area above grade
- 3,702 sq ft
- Unfinished area above grade
- 1,851 sq ft
- Unfinished area below grade
- 1,851 sq ft
- Below grade total
- 1,851 sq ft
- Bedrooms above grade
- 5
- Full baths, main level
- 1
- Full baths, upper level
- 2
- Basement
- Unfinished
- Flooring
- Hardwood
- Heating
- Natural Gas
- Cooling
- Central Air
- Laundry
- Main Level
- Interior features
- Attic-Walk-up
Exterior & parking
- Style
- Historic, Victorian
- Construction
- Brick, Concrete
- Foundation
- Brick/Mortar
- Garage spaces
- 3
- Attached garage
- Yes
- Garage type
- Attached
- Garage sq ft
- 528 sq ft
- Private pool
- No
- Other structures
- Detached Garage
- New construction
- No
Waterfront & lake
- Waterfront
- No
Lot
- Lot features
- Corner Lot
- Lot size (acres)
- 0.92 ac
- Lot dimensions
- 120x917
- County
- St. Joseph County
- Township
- Olive
- Platted
- Yes
- Planned unit development
- No
- Directions
- Head west on US 20 towards New Carlisle. Take a right onto Thunderbird Drive. The Property will be the house on the corner of these two roads.
Schools
- Elementary school
- Olive Twp
- Middle school
- New Prairie
- High school
- New Prairie
- School district
- New Prairie United School Corp.
Taxes & terms
- Annual taxes
- $9,025
- Tax year
- 2025
- Possession
- Day of Closing
- Parcel number
- 71-01-34-178-003.000-018
Included in the sale
- Included in sale
- Dishwasher,Microwave,Refrigerator,Cooktop-Gas
Utilities
- Water
- City
- Sewer
- Septic Tank
Income & commercial
- Gas meters
- 22
Location
Similar homes
$489,900
Listed Sep 2555751 Wood Duck Court
New Carlisle, IN 46552
- 3 beds
- 2.5 baths
- 2,004 sq ft
Listing courtesy of Irish Realty
$675,000
8173 E Walnut Ridge
New Carlisle, IN 46552
- 4 beds
- 3.5 baths
- 4,876 sq ft
Listing courtesy of Re/Max County Wide 1st
$454,900
Listed Jul 22712 Gentry Lane
New Carlisle, IN 46552
- 4 beds
- 2.5 baths
- 2,507 sq ft
Listing courtesy of McColly Real Estate


