Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Group · Listing agent: Jessy Sims · jessysims@kw.com
Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS.
591 S 500 E
$375,000
Columbia City, IN 46725
Listed at $370,000 Sold March 20, 2026
- 2.5 acres
- Pool
- Basement
- Bedrooms
- 4
- Bathrooms
- 2
- Living area
- 2,076 sq ft
- Lot
- 2.48 ac
- Year built
- 1900
- Type
- Site-Built Home
- Listed
- February 26, 2026
- MLS #
- 202606089
About this home
Welcome to this charming country home situated on a peaceful 2.5 acres, offering over 2,000 sq ft of updated living space. This two-story farmhouse features 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a versatile bonus room that can serve as a breakfast nook, home office, or additional living space. The kitchen includes an eat-in dining with built-in storage bench seating under the windows, and the main level offers a comfortable living area plus a flex room for added functionality. The primary bedroom is conveniently located on the main level with its own ensuite bath. New flooring and thoughtful updates run throughout the home, showcasing how well-kept and maintained this property is inside and out. Outside, you’ll find tasteful landscaping, some fruit trees, an above-ground pool for all the summer fun, and a shed/coup. The impressive 60X32 pole barn features two overhead doors (one 10ft high), updated electrical, with plenty of storage and workspace. Kitchen appliances remain with the home.
Property details
Interior
- Levels
- Two
- Total rooms
- 9
- Total area
- 2,294 sq ft
- Finished area above grade
- 2,076 sq ft
- Unfinished area below grade
- 218 sq ft
- Below grade total
- 218 sq ft
- Bedrooms above grade
- 4
- Full baths, main level
- 2
- Basement
- Crawl Space, Partial
- Heating
- Propane, Forced Air, Heat Pump
- Cooling
- Central Air
- Appliances
- Disposal
- Laundry
- Electric Dryer Hookup, Main Level
- Interior features
- 1st Bdrm En Suite, Ceiling Fan(s), Range/Oven Hook Up Elec
Exterior & parking
- Construction
- Vinyl Siding
- Roof
- Shingle
- Private pool
- Yes
- Pool
- Above Ground
- Other structures
- Pole/Post Building
- Outbuilding 1
- 1,984 sq ft
- New construction
- No
Waterfront & lake
- Waterfront
- No
Lot
- Lot features
- Level, 0-2.9999
- Lot size (acres)
- 2.48 ac
- Lot dimensions
- 390x277
- Location type
- Rural
- Inside city limits
- No
- County
- Whitley County
- Township
- Union
- Cross street
- E Old Trail Road
- Road frontage
- County Road
- Road surface
- Gravel
- Platted
- Yes
- Planned unit development
- No
- Directions
- Property can easily be found on Google Maps.
Schools
- Elementary school
- Coesse
- Middle school
- Indian Springs
- High school
- Columbia City
- School district
- Whitley CO Cons Schools
Taxes & terms
- Annual taxes
- $1,436
- Tax year
- 2025
- Tax exemptions
- Homestead
- Listing terms
- Cash, Conventional
- Possession
- DOC
- Parcel number
- 92-05-10-000-307.000-012
Included in the sale
- Included in sale
- Dishwasher,Microwave,Refrigerator,Pool Equipment,Water Heater Electric
Utilities
- Water
- Well
- Well
- Private
- Sewer
- Septic Tank
Income & commercial
- Gas meters
- 17
Location
Schools
School district
Whitley County Consolidated Schools
From the district boundary map (NCES)
3,620 students · Graduation rate: 94.9% (Indiana 91.8%)
Confirm the schools for this address with Whitley County Consolidated SchoolsGrades K–5
Coesse SchoolPublic · Grades K–5 · 304 students · 1.7 mi away
As listed by the listing agent
- English (ILEARN)
- 50.7% · Indiana 42%
- Math (ILEARN)
- 45.1% · Indiana 42.7%
Grades 6–8
Indian Springs Middle SchoolPublic · Grades 6–8 · 794 students · 5 mi away
The only school for these grades in Whitley County Consolidated Schools
- English (ILEARN)
- 47.4% · Indiana 42%
- Math (ILEARN)
- 33.3% · Indiana 42.7%
Grades 9–12
Columbia City High SchoolPublic · Grades 9–12 · 1,184 students · 4.7 mi away
The only school for these grades in Whitley County Consolidated Schools
- Graduation rate
- 94.9% · Indiana 91.8%
- SAT reading & writing
- 54% · Indiana 51.9%
- SAT math
- 23.2% · Indiana 25.6%
Public schools nearby (2)
- Mary Raber Elementary School
Public · Grades PK–5 · 257 students · 4.3 mi away
- Little Turtle Elementary School
Public · Grades K–5 · 546 students · 4.8 mi away
Private schools nearby (2)
- T.R.O.Y. Center
Private · Nonsectarian · Grades 6–12 · 38 students · 3.1 mi away · Takes Choice Scholarships
- Faith Christian Academy
Private · Christian · Grades PK–8 · 29 students · 3.5 mi away
Figures: enrollment (2025-26 school year), ILEARN (spring 2026), graduation rate (class of 2025), SAT (spring 2026), and private school enrollment (2023-24 school year).
ILEARN: share of students in grades 3–8 proficient on Indiana's state test. SAT: share of 11th graders meeting the college-readiness benchmark. Distances are in a straight line.
Sources: U.S. Department of Education, NCES Common Core of Data; U.S. Department of Education, NCES EDGE school district boundaries; Indiana Department of Education, Data Center & Reports; U.S. Department of Education, NCES Private School Survey; Indiana Department of Education, Choice Scholarship participating schools.
Indiana Home Match doesn't rate or rank schools. Attendance boundaries change, so confirm with the district before you buy.

Area guide
Living in Columbia City
Neighborhoods, schools, cost of living and local housing trends — our guide to life in Columbia City.
Read the Columbia City guide




