Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Bradley Realty, Inc · Listing agent: Gregory Brown · Cell: 260-602-5297
Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS.
5540 N Willow Avenue
$253,100
Columbia City, IN 46725-9322North Shoes(s) / Northshore(s)
Listed at $289,900 Sold April 24, 2026
- On Shriner Lake
- 2-car garage
- Fireplace
- Basement
- Bedrooms
- 3
- Bathrooms
- 2
- Living area
- 1,601 sq ft
- Lot
- 0.13 ac
- Year built
- 1890
- Type
- Site-Built Home
- Listed
- December 7, 2025
- MLS #
- 202548292
About this home
*This inviting 3 Bedroom and 2 FULL Bath potential year-round lake home with a basement on Shriner Lake offers an exceptional lakefront lifestyle with everything you need to enjoy the water! *Experience direct access to the clear waters of Shriner Lake, complete with deeded rights to a 1.87 Acre parcel right in front of your home and the pier is included with the sale! *Customize your lakefront space with piers, boat moorings, and endless outdoor activities. *Retreat to the large primary bedroom, featuring a private full bath and breathtaking views of the lake, creating a peaceful oasis for relaxation. *The bright and airy eat-in kitchen is fully equipped with newer LG appliances, making it the ideal space for preparing meals and entertaining friends. *With a 2-car attached garage, new roof and gutters (installed Fall 2023), and generous storage throughout both the main and lower levels, this home has all your practical needs covered. *Enjoy multiple spaces to unwind plus Big Eyed Fish and Portside Pizza are just around the corner. *The family room offers stunning lake views and a cozy gas-vented fireplace, while an additional living area provides extra space for leisure or entertaining. *The home features a charming 3-season room and a spacious deck that spans the entire width of the house, offering panoramic views of the lake — the perfect spot to relax, dine, or watch the sunset. *The newly constructed home behind this property is also for sale, offering further possibilities for expansion or investment. *Shriner Lake is ideal for water sports, allowing skiing daily from 1-4 pm. *The perfect spot for boating, fishing, and more! *Move in and start enjoying lake life right away!
Property details
Interior
- Levels
- One
- Total rooms
- 5
- Total area
- 2,087 sq ft
- Finished area above grade
- 1,392 sq ft
- Finished area below grade
- 209 sq ft
- Unfinished area below grade
- 486 sq ft
- Below grade total
- 695 sq ft
- Bedrooms above grade
- 3
- Full baths, main level
- 2
- Basement
- Sump Pump, Partial, Partially Finished
- Flooring
- Carpet, Tile
- Heating
- Natural Gas, Forced Air
- Cooling
- Central Air
- Fireplaces
- 1
- Fireplace features
- Family Room, Gas Log, Vented
- Appliances
- Disposal
- Interior features
- 1st Bdrm En Suite, Attic Pull Down Stairs, Breakfast Bar, Ceiling Fan(s), Vaulted Ceiling(s), Walk-In Closet(s), Countertops-Laminate, Crown Molding, Detector-Smoke, Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Natural Woodwork, Stand Up Shower, Tub/Shower Combination, Main Level Bedroom Suite, Washer Hook-Up
Exterior & parking
- Style
- Ranch
- Construction
- Stone, Vinyl Siding
- Roof
- Metal
- Foundation
- Block
- Garage spaces
- 2
- Garage type
- Basement
- Garage sq ft
- 440 sq ft
- Parking
- Garage Door Opener, Gravel
- Private pool
- No
- Fencing
- Partial, Chain Link
- New construction
- No
Waterfront & lake
- Waterfront
- Yes
- Body of water
- Shriner Lake
- Waterfront features
- Pier/Dock, Deeded
- Water access
- Easement/Other
- Lake type
- Ski Lake
- Water frontage
- 50 ft
- Channel / canal frontage
- 50 ft
- Water feature
- Lake
Lot
- Subdivision
- North Shoes(s) / Northshore(s)
- Lot features
- Level, Waterfront, Lake on Lot
- Lot size (acres)
- 0.13 ac
- Lot dimensions
- 50X110
- Location type
- Lake
- County
- Whitley County
- Township
- Thorn Creek
- Lots
- 0
- Platted
- Yes
- Planned unit development
- No
- Directions
- US 30 W. to Columbia City, rt on SR 9 to 500 N., Rt and follow around lake & house is on the left.
Schools
- Elementary school
- Northern Heights
- Middle school
- Indian Springs
- High school
- Columbia City
- School district
- Whitley CO Cons Schools
Taxes & terms
- Annual taxes
- $5,496
- Tax year
- 2025
- Listing terms
- Cash, Conventional, FHA, VA
- Possession
- At Closing
- Parcel number
- 92-03-12-456-002.000-011
Included in the sale
- Included in sale
- Dishwasher,Microwave,Refrigerator,Oven-Electric,Range-Electric,Water Heater Gas
Utilities
- Water
- Well
- Well
- Private
- Sewer
- Public Sewer
- Utilities
- Cable Available
- Electric provider
- AEP/I&M
Location
Schools
School district
Whitley County Consolidated Schools
From the district boundary map (NCES)
3,620 students · Graduation rate: 94.9% (Indiana 91.8%)
Confirm the schools for this address with Whitley County Consolidated SchoolsGrades K–5
Northern Heights Elementary SchoolPublic · Grades K–5 · 523 students · 2.8 mi away
As listed by the listing agent
- English (ILEARN)
- 46.3% · Indiana 42%
- Math (ILEARN)
- 55.6% · Indiana 42.7%
Grades 6–8
Indian Springs Middle SchoolPublic · Grades 6–8 · 794 students · 8 mi away
The only school for these grades in Whitley County Consolidated Schools
- English (ILEARN)
- 47.4% · Indiana 42%
- Math (ILEARN)
- 33.3% · Indiana 42.7%
Grades 9–12
Columbia City High SchoolPublic · Grades 9–12 · 1,184 students · 7.6 mi away
The only school for these grades in Whitley County Consolidated Schools
- Graduation rate
- 94.9% · Indiana 91.8%
- SAT reading & writing
- 54% · Indiana 51.9%
- SAT math
- 23.2% · Indiana 25.6%
Public schools nearby (1)
- Churubusco Jr-Sr High School
Public · Grades 6–12 · 624 students · 6.1 mi away
Private schools nearby (1)
- Cornerstone Christian School
Private · Christian · Grades K–12 · 51 students · 3.2 mi away
Figures: enrollment (2025-26 school year), ILEARN (spring 2026), graduation rate (class of 2025), SAT (spring 2026), and private school enrollment (2023-24 school year).
ILEARN: share of students in grades 3–8 proficient on Indiana's state test. SAT: share of 11th graders meeting the college-readiness benchmark. Distances are in a straight line.
Sources: U.S. Department of Education, NCES Common Core of Data; U.S. Department of Education, NCES EDGE school district boundaries; Indiana Department of Education, Data Center & Reports; U.S. Department of Education, NCES Private School Survey.
Indiana Home Match doesn't rate or rank schools. Attendance boundaries change, so confirm with the district before you buy.

Area guide
Living in Columbia City
Neighborhoods, schools, cost of living and local housing trends — our guide to life in Columbia City.
Read the Columbia City guide







