Listing courtesy of Raeco Realty · Listing agent: Cody Miller
5255 E Bay Front Court
Monticello, IN 47960Keans Bay
Original price $279,900 · Price reduced on August 7, 2026
- On Lake Shafer
- Fireplace
- Bedrooms
- 2
- Bathrooms
- 1
- Living area
- 840 sq ft
- Lot
- 0.21 ac
- Year built
- 1960
- Type
- Site-Built Home
- Listed
- April 3, 2026
- MLS #
- 202611348
About this home
Welcome to 5255 E Bay Front Court, a stunningly renovated lakefront home nestled on the serene shores of Lake Shafer. Situated on the most sought after private and peaceful bayfront, Keans Bay. This property offers the perfect blend of modern luxury and relaxed lakeside living, making it an ideal year-round residence, vacation home, or investment opportunity. Stepping inside, you'll discover a completely updated interior featuring high-end finishes, remarkable craftsmanship, and an open-concept layout. The gourmet kitchen features custom cabinetry, quartz countertops, tiled-backsplash, and stainless steel appliances, seamlessly flowing into the spacious living and dining areas—perfect for entertaining or unwinding with family and friends. Outdoor living is equally impressive, with a large deck, stepping stone pavers, carport, shed, and a deeded private lot w/ new dock/seawall and boat lift for direct access to boating, fishing, and all that Lake Shafer has to offer. Located in a quiet, sought-after neighborhood, this turn-key lake home provides both privacy and convenience—just minutes from Indiana Beach, dining, shopping, and local attractions. Other noteworthy details include new ac/furnace, tankless water heater, siding, roof, electrical (200 amp), and water lines. You don’t find affordable, move-in-ready lake homes like this—here’s your chance to own something truly special. Schedule today!
Monthly payment estimate
$1,539/mo
- Principal & interest
- $1,368
- Property taxes
- $98
- Homeowners insurance
- $73
- Rate: Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average for the week of October 1, 2026.
- Taxes: the seller's 2024 bill as reported to the MLS. Yours may differ once your own deductions apply.
- Insurance: estimated at 0.35% of the price per year.
- An estimate, not a loan offer. Your rate and payment depend on your credit, loan program and down payment.
Get pre-approved
Know your real budget before you tour, and make a stronger offer. We'll connect you with a local lender.
Property details
Interior
- Levels
- One
- Total rooms
- 6
- Total area
- 840 sq ft
- Finished area above grade
- 840 sq ft
- Bedrooms above grade
- 2
- Full baths, main level
- 1
- Basement
- Crawl Space
- Heating
- Forced Air
- Cooling
- Central Air
- Fireplaces
- 1
- Fireplace features
- Electric
- Laundry
- Main Level
Exterior & parking
- Construction
- Vinyl Siding
- Private pool
- No
- Other structures
- Shed(s)
- New construction
- No
Waterfront & lake
- Waterfront
- Yes
- Body of water
- Lake Shafer
- Water access
- Bayfront
- Lake type
- Ski Lake
- Water frontage
- 13 ft
- Water feature
- Lake
Lot
- Subdivision
- Keans Bay
- Lot features
- Level
- Lot size (acres)
- 0.21 ac
- Lot dimensions
- IRR
- County
- White County
- Township
- Liberty
- Platted
- Yes
- Planned unit development
- No
- Directions
- GPS Friendly
Schools
- Elementary school
- Twin Lakes
- Middle school
- Twin Lakes
- High school
- Twin Lakes
- School district
- Twin Lakes School Corp.
Taxes & terms
- Annual taxes
- $1,181
- Tax year
- 2024
- Possession
- NEGOTIABLE
- Parcel number
- 91-73-09-000-021.100-011
Utilities
- Water
- Well
- Well
- Private
- Sewer
- Regional
Location
Similar homes
2 homes for sale in Keans Bay$250,000
510 N Illinois Street
Monticello, IN 47960
- 4 beds
- 2 baths
- 1,792 sq ft
Listing courtesy of Indiana Realty Group
$250,000
Listed Oct 86859 N 1225 W
Monticello, IN 47960-6505
- 3 beds
- 1 bath
- 1,536 sq ft
Listing courtesy of Trueblood Real Estate
$249,000
Listed Sep 216506 E 250 N Road
Monticello, IN 47960
- 3 beds
- 2 baths
- 1,864 sq ft
Listing courtesy of Redlow Group
