Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Group · Listing agent: James Reecer · jreecer@kw.com

Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS.

Virtual tour
SoldSite-Built Home

444 S Butterstone Trail

$682,500

Columbia City, IN 46725Lake Trail Estates

Listed at $674,900 Sold June 11, 2025

  • 3.4 acres
  • 2-car garage
  • Fireplace
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
2.5
Living area
3,042 sq ft
Lot
3.43 ac
Year built
2010
Type
Site-Built Home
Listed
May 9, 2025
MLS #
202516773

About this home

Welcome to this exceptional 3/4 bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home in a picturesque rural subdivision, offering the perfect blend of upscale living and natural beauty. Set on nearly 3.5 acres, this property is part of a limited 12-lot community that shares scenic walking paths and a private community pond—ideal for fishing, kayaking, swimming from rafts, gathering around the fire pit, or enjoying the sandy beach. Step inside the inviting foyer and discover a thoughtfully designed interior with quality finishes throughout. The living room features a cozy gas fireplace framed by elegant built-ins, creating a warm and welcoming space for relaxation. The kitchen is a chef’s dream, showcasing custom Grabill cabinetry with premium features such as a bread drawer, silverware inserts, an appliance garage, and a spacious pantry. Granite countertops elevate both the kitchen and bathrooms, complemented by tiled shower surrounds. The primary suite is a true retreat, complete with separate his-and-hers walk-in closets, a large garden tub, and direct access to the conveniently connected laundry room with built-in hampers. Both additional bedrooms feature double closets, providing ample storage. A versatile den/office offers flexible living space and 4th bedroom option, while the partially finished bonus room above the garage and walk-up attic add even more storage options. Outdoor living is a highlight, with a stunning screened-in back patio featuring remote-controlled, retractable screens installed in July 2024—an ideal space to unwind and enjoy the surrounding views. The property also boasts extensive landscaping and a detached two-car garage for additional convenience. Recent updates include new hardwood laminate flooring in 2022 and fresh carpet in 2021, reflecting the meticulous care the home has received. Whether you’re looking for space to spread out indoors or a peaceful outdoor retreat, this home has it all. Schedule a showing today and experience the perfect blend of luxury and nature firsthand.

Property details

Interior

Levels
One and One Half
Total rooms
8
Total area
3,042 sq ft
Finished area above grade
3,042 sq ft
Main level
2,588 sq ft
Upper level
454 sq ft
Bedrooms above grade
3
Full baths, main level
2
Half baths, main level
1
Basement
Slab
Heating
Natural Gas, Forced Air
Cooling
Central Air
Fireplaces
1
Fireplace features
Living/Great Rm
Appliances
Disposal
Laundry
Electric Dryer Hookup, Gas Dryer Hookup, Main Level
Interior features
1st Bdrm En Suite, Alarm System-Security, Storage, Attic-Walk-up, Breakfast Bar, Built-in Features, High Ceilings, Ceiling-Tray, Ceiling Fan(s), Walk-In Closet(s), Countertops-Stone, Detector-Smoke, Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Garden Tub, Kitchen Island, Natural Woodwork, Near Walking Trail, Pantry, Split Br Floor Plan, Double Vanity, Utility Sink, Stand Up Shower, Tub and Separate Shower, Tub/Shower Combination, Workshop, Main Level Bedroom Suite, Great Room, Main Floor Laundry, Washer Hook-Up, Custom Cabinetry, Garage Utilities

Exterior & parking

Construction
Stone, Vinyl Siding, Wood Siding
Roof
Asphalt
Garage spaces
2
Attached garage
Yes
Garage type
Attached
Garage sq ft
572 sq ft
Parking
Garage Door Opener
Private pool
No
Other structures
Detached Garage
New construction
No

Waterfront & lake

Waterfront
No
Water access
Easement/Other
Water feature
Lake

Lot

Subdivision
Lake Trail Estates
Lot features
Landscaped, Corner Lot, Level
Lot size (acres)
3.43 ac
Lot dimensions
225x600
Location type
Rural Subdivision
County
Whitley County
Township
Union
Platted
Yes
Planned unit development
No
Directions
From Columbia City, head east on E Van Buren St, crossing US 30 and continuing on Old Trail Rd. Turn right onto Old Trail Rd when it splits from IN 205. Turn left onto S Butterstone Trail, after CR 600 E. First home on the left.

Schools

Elementary school
Coesse
Middle school
Indian Springs
High school
Columbia City
School district
Whitley CO Cons Schools

HOA & community

HOA fee
$340
HOA fee frequency
Annually
Association restrictions
Yes

Taxes & terms

Annual taxes
$3,806
Tax year
2025
Listing terms
Cash, Conventional
Possession
Negotiable
Parcel number
92-05-11-404-008.000-012

Included in the sale

Included in sale
Dishwasher,Microwave,Window Treatments,Cooktop-Electric,Kitchen Exhaust Hood,Oven-Built-In,Water Heater Electric,Water Softener-Owned
Excluded from sale
Starlink Antenna

Utilities

Water
Well
Well
Private
Sewer
Septic Tank

Location

Loading map...

Schools

School district

Whitley County Consolidated Schools

From the district boundary map (NCES)

3,620 students · Graduation rate: 94.9% (Indiana 91.8%)

Confirm the schools for this address with Whitley County Consolidated Schools
  • Grades K–5

    Coesse School

    Public · Grades K–5 · 304 students · 2.2 mi away

    As listed by the listing agent

    English (ILEARN)
    50.7% · Indiana 42%
    Math (ILEARN)
    45.1% · Indiana 42.7%
  • Grades 6–8

    Indian Springs Middle School

    Public · Grades 6–8 · 794 students · 6.2 mi away

    The only school for these grades in Whitley County Consolidated Schools

    English (ILEARN)
    47.4% · Indiana 42%
    Math (ILEARN)
    33.3% · Indiana 42.7%
  • Grades 9–12

    Columbia City High School

    Public · Grades 9–12 · 1,184 students · 6 mi away

    The only school for these grades in Whitley County Consolidated Schools

    Graduation rate
    94.9% · Indiana 91.8%
    SAT reading & writing
    54% · Indiana 51.9%
    SAT math
    23.2% · Indiana 25.6%
Public schools nearby (5)
Private schools nearby (2)
  • T.R.O.Y. Center

    Private · Nonsectarian · Grades 6–12 · 38 students · 4.4 mi away · Takes Choice Scholarships

  • Faith Christian Academy

    Private · Christian · Grades PK–8 · 29 students · 4.7 mi away

Figures: enrollment (2025-26 school year), ILEARN (spring 2026), graduation rate (class of 2025), SAT (spring 2026), and private school enrollment (2023-24 school year).

ILEARN: share of students in grades 3–8 proficient on Indiana's state test. SAT: share of 11th graders meeting the college-readiness benchmark. Distances are in a straight line.

Sources: U.S. Department of Education, NCES Common Core of Data; U.S. Department of Education, NCES EDGE school district boundaries; Indiana Department of Education, Data Center & Reports; U.S. Department of Education, NCES Private School Survey; Indiana Department of Education, Choice Scholarship participating schools.

Indiana Home Match doesn't rate or rank schools. Attendance boundaries change, so confirm with the district before you buy.

Area guide

Living in Columbia City

Neighborhoods, schools, cost of living and local housing trends — our guide to life in Columbia City.

Read the Columbia City guide

$682,500

3 beds · 2.5 baths