Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group · Listing agent: Jami Stamm · Cell: 574-596-4868
435 S Main Street
Middlebury, IN 46540-9767
Original price $460,000 · Price reduced on August 2, 2026
- Basement
- Bedrooms
- 4
- Bathrooms
- 5
- Living area
- 4,112 sq ft
- Lot
- 0.57 ac
- Year built
- 1900
- Type
- Duplex
- Listed
- July 23, 2026
- MLS #
- 202629722
About this home
Imagine owning a charming home just steps from the heart of one of Northern Indiana's most beloved tourist destinations. Located on historic Main Street in the quaint town of Middlebury, this property offers the ideal setting for a short-term rental, boutique Airbnb, or weekend getaway. The home sits on the Pumpkinvine Nature Trail and is just minutes away from Shipshewana's famous flea market and auctions, the Essenhaus Inn & Restaurant, Amish countryside tours, and endless opportunities for shopping, dining, and outdoor recreation. Whether visitors are coming for a girls' weekend, cycling adventure, Amish country experience, or Notre Dame football weekend, this location places them in the center of it all. Picture cozy gathering spaces, 4 thoughtfully designed bedrooms, and charming outdoor areas where guests can unwind after a day of exploring. With Middlebury's year-round tourism and limited boutique lodging options, this property presents an exciting opportunity to generate income while owning a piece of one of Indiana's most picturesque small towns. Whether you're looking to expand your investment portfolio or create a destination property with lasting appeal, this property offers location, charm, and exceptional Airbnb potential in one of the Midwest's hidden gems. All with a bonus apartment that could be rented!
Monthly payment estimate
$2,840/mo
- Principal & interest
- $2,326
- Property taxes
- $390
- Homeowners insurance
- $124
- Rate: Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average for the week of October 1, 2026.
- Taxes: estimated at 1.1% of the price per year — the MLS reports no full tax bill for this home yet.
- Insurance: estimated at 0.35% of the price per year.
- An estimate, not a loan offer. Your rate and payment depend on your credit, loan program and down payment.
Get pre-approved
Know your real budget before you tour, and make a stronger offer. We'll connect you with a local lender.
Property details
Interior
- Levels
- Two
- Stories
- 2
- Total area
- 4,112 sq ft
- Finished area above grade
- 2,540 sq ft
- Finished area below grade
- 1,572 sq ft
- Main level
- 1,270 sq ft
- Upper level
- 1,270 sq ft
- Below grade total
- 1,572 sq ft
- Bedrooms above grade
- 4
- Basement
- Walk-Out Basement
- Flooring
- Carpet, Laminate, Wood
- Heating
- Natural Gas, Forced Air
- Cooling
- Central Air
- Amenities
- Basement, Fireplace, Off Street Parking, Near Walking Trail
Exterior & parking
- Construction
- Vinyl Siding, Wood Siding
- Private pool
- No
- New construction
- No
Waterfront & lake
- Waterfront
- No
Lot
- Lot features
- Level
- Lot size (acres)
- 0.57 ac
- Lot dimensions
- 132x219
- County
- Elkhart County
- Township
- Middlebury
- Platted
- Yes
- Planned unit development
- No
- Directions
- From US 20, turn North on SR 13
Schools
- Elementary school
- Middlebury
- Middle school
- Northridge
- High school
- Northridge
- School district
- Middlebury Community Schools
HOA & community
- Association restrictions
- No
Taxes & terms
- Tax year
- 2026
- Assessed value
- $354,800
- Listing terms
- Cash, Conventional
- Possession
- At funded closing
- Parcel number
- 20-08-10-380-016.000-035
Included in the sale
- Included in sale
- Building
Utilities
- Water
- City
- Sewer
- Public Sewer
Income & commercial
- Units
- 2
- Parking spaces
- 6
- Pets allowed
- No
- Electric meters
- 1
- Gas meters
- 1
- Water meters
- 1