Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity · Listing agent: Ashley Morris · Cell: 765-524-8599

Virtual tour
ActiveMixed Use

423 S 11Th Street

$264,900

$45.33 / sq ft

New Castle, IN 47362-4629

Original price $274,900 · Price reduced on September 28, 2026

  • Basement
Estimate your monthly payment
Bathrooms
4
Lot
0.64 ac
Year built
1900
Type
Mixed Use
Listed
May 4, 2026
MLS #
202616482

About this home

Opportunity awaits with this well-located, former church property right in the center of New Castle. Situated in an established neighborhood, this distinctive, 5,844 sq ft building offers a versatile layout to fit a variety of needs. On the main level, the property features a large foyer entry with public restrooms. The foyer leads into the spacious sanctuary with vaulted ceilings and original stained glass windows. There is also a sound booth with a sound system included. Two additional rooms on the main level offer potential classroom, office, or storage options. On the lower level, you'll find a great room perfect for entertainment and gatherings conveniently located by the impressive, fully operational kitchen and two additional public restroom areas. The remaining 3 rooms would work great for office space, classrooms, or other needs. Outdoors, the property is a total of 1.22 acres with a large front yard, detached garage, covered drop off area, and private parking lot with +/- 38 spaces. The personal property in the facility is all included in the sale.

Property details

Interior

Stories
2
Finished area above grade
5,844 sq ft
Basement
Finished, Full
Flooring
Carpet
Heating
Natural Gas, Forced Air
Cooling
Central Air

Exterior & parking

Construction
Brick
Roof
Shingle
Parking
Asphalt, Concrete, Gravel, Parking Lot, Off Street, Paved
New construction
No

Waterfront & lake

Waterfront
No

Lot

Lot size (acres)
0.64 ac
Lot dimensions
150X184.3
Location type
City
County
Henry County
Township
Henry
Current use
Place of Worship, School
Road frontage
City Street
Lots
0
Platted
Yes
Planned unit development
No
Directions
GPA Friendly

Taxes & terms

Tax year
2026
Assessed value
$152,300
Tax exemptions
Tax Exempt
Tax abatement
No
Possession
DOC
Parcel number
33-12-15-210-249.000-016

Included in the sale

Included in sale
Building

Utilities

Water
City
Sewer
Public Sewer
Utilities
Mun. Sewer to Site, Mun. Water to Site
Electric provider
Duke Energy Indiana
Gas provider
CenterPoint Energy
Water provider
New Castle Utility

Income & commercial

Water meters
2
Ceiling height
8'

Location

Loading map...

Similar homes

$264,900

4 baths